“Fueling terrorism”: It’s always “our” fault

By SETH J. FRANTZMAN

There is always a narrative about “fueling” terrorism.

1950s-1960s Why is there terrorism
“Colonialism fuels terrorism

1970s Why is there terrorism?
“Israel is fueling terrorism by suppressing Palestinians and its occupation of Arab and Islamic lands”

1980s Why is there terrorism?
“US policy in Iran fueled the revolution that then became extreme and caused terrorism, and US support of Mujahidin in Afghanistan caused terrorism”

Early 1990s Why is there terrorism?
“US-supported regimes and secular dictators and lack of democracy fuel terror by suppressing the demands of the people”

Late 1990s and 9/11 Why is there terrorism?
“US bases in the Kingdom on the land of the two holy sites defiles Islam and fuels terrorism and US role in Afghanistan created blowback, as well as US support for Israel.”

2002 Why is there terrorism?
Poverty and discrimination cause terrorism as well as dictatorship in the Arab world”

2003 Why is there terrorism?
“The US and allied invasion of Iraq fueled extremism

2004-2014 Why is there terrorism?
“Lack of jobs, global warming and opportunity forces young men to become radicalized in Europe and fuels extremism”

2014 Why is there terrorism
“Assad’s crackdown on demands for democracy and Maliki’s disenfranchisement of Sunni Arabs in Iraq fuels terrorism”

2015-2016 Why is there terrorism?
“The rise of the right wing in Europe and racism fuels extremism and terrorism

2017 Why is there terrorism?
“Donald Trump’s immigration ban fuels extremism and terrorism.”

 

May I propose an alternative theory of how extremism is fueled.

Extremism is primarily fueled by hateful and intolerant societies that produce large numbers of ignorant and bigoted people who are willing dupes, fellow travelers, useful idiots, and some of whome are actual extremists. Within such a society there are also those on its margins, even outsiders, who seek to convert to zealotry because it provides an easy answer and there are psychopaths and sociopaths who seek an excuse to murder others.

Into this society comes voices who exploit the existing bigotry, ignorance and intolerance and encourages people to become extremist terrorists. They exploit the existing and non-existing grievances of the people through preaching and other forms of propaganda using the most modern medium and religion as a cover or rubric to bring in the public. Very small numbers of people join with the extremists, but even a very small number (.01%) of society willing to commit mass murder can wreak havoc.

The extremist group perpetuates not only lies and propaganda (such as claiming religious books were burned in order to encourage a crowd to murder), but invents new “grievances” every year as a new “reason” for people to kill others. Much as the KKK or Nazis had their “reasons” and they were “fueled” by often imagined suffering, these extremist groups prey on the same need of people to hate the other and blame others for their problem.

So one year they will say “poverty made me kill” and the next year they will say “racism in Europe made me do it” and then “Trump made me do it,” but the reality is that nothing made them extremist except for themselves, extremism isn’t “fueled,” it often fuels itself.

Most dictatorships full of poor discriminated against people don’t create masses of terrorists, in fact most places produce zero extremism. Extremism requires mobilization. Of course it has excuses as to what mobilizes it, but there is always a reason. When Saddam Hussein was in charge he committed genocide and terror against Shia and Kurds, and when he lost power others stepped into his place as “resistance” and killed Shia and Kurds. They always had their reason, whether in charge or not. Just like the KKK when it was in charge (in the form of white supremacy before 1865) it terrorized black people and when it was marginalized it terrorized them, and always had an excuse as to why.

Be wary of the self-fulfilling prophecy of “fueling terror,” its the easy way to excuse hatred and mass murder.

Of course one can reduce the number of people to whome a radicalization appeal may be interesting, but it will always be there.

One response to ““Fueling terrorism”: It’s always “our” fault

  1. Great article.
    Infantilisng the enemy as seemingly being unable to control itself won`t work in a primary school-so how they expect it to work with bearded psychopathic Sunnis is beyond me.
    No, Islam is the sole cause-once allied to serial misfits and deviants who somehow persuade themselves to lose their own lives in the hope they`ll get another one after.
    Islam needs caging and boxing up, when its more literal idiots are not dealt with. Islam itself won`t do this-we have no Nassers any more.
    So it`ll have to be Donald Trump and the new wave of politicians in E.Europe who`ll have to do it.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s