Tracking the fallout, reactions and details of the NYT antisemitic cartoon scandal

By SETH J. FRANTZMAN

On April 27 media around the world began to react to an antisemitic cartoon that appeared in the April 25 edition, page 16, of the International Edition of The New York Times.

My coverage and reactions

My coverage of the NYT antisemitic cartoon scandal
7. Mentioned in Breitbart “Seth Frantzman of the Jerusalem Post shared his thoughts on the cartoon, which appeared next to a column by Thomas Friedman and said,” https://www.breitbart.com/politics/2019/04/27/new-york-times-publishes-antisemitic-offensive-cartoon-forced-to-apologize/

Reactions

  • The New York Times says it made an error.
Screen Shot 2019-04-27 at 5.43.01 PM
  • New York Times International Edition editor re-tweets the editor’s note at around 3pm London time.
Screen Shot 2019-04-27 at 10.44.48 PM.png
  • Barak Ravid notes that the NYT has not actually apologized.
  • AJC slams the lack of apology “Apology not accepted. How many @nytimes editors looked at a cartoon that would not have looked out of place on a white supremacist website and thought it met the paper’s editorial standards? What does this say about your processes or your decision makers? How are you fixing it?” Jake Tapper at CNN re-tweets this. AJC also wrote “Naked antisemitism such as in this image is not “an error of judgment.” We have to wonder if the NYT editors would’ve published a similar cartoon depicting any other country or people.”
  • Bryan Leib notes “It’s sad that NYT Opinion would publish this anti-semitic filfth but when two of the youngest Jewish American Congressional candidates send the #nytimes an op-ed calling on #Congress to get serious & to act immediately to fund #Holocaust #Education– they won’t publish it.”
  • Joshua Zeitz “Funny that they didn’t pull that shit in the US edition, published in New York City, with the largest metro area Jewish population in the disaspora. It’s almost like they may actually have known it was offensive.”
  • Joyce Karam “The cartoon is disgusting and sloppy, more so for being printed in NYTimes. Good that they issued a statement, retracted it but this is alarming. Many publications peddle anti-semitism, racism, Islomophobia in Middle East but they are not the New York Times. Unfortunate.”
  • Yashar Ali writes “Here’s the anti-Semitic cartoon that the NYT published”
  • Kobby Barda head of “GAL” program for community leadership, The academic center for Law and Science, says he helped bring this to the attention of multiple people. “We won, the New York Post apologizes for an antisemitic caricature. My lesson from the story? Not to give up when you see evil and injustice, to stand up for your rights and not to remain silent. Especially during the week of Holocaust Remembrance Day in Israel.”
  • Harry Cherry at The Jewish Voice “This apology isn’t enough. How many editors approved it? How did it make it’s way into the paper? There needs to be a wide-reaching investigation.”
  • Peter Lerner says “1. Are you still working with the “news service and syndicate”? 2. What steps are you doing so that there is a price to pay for spreading such hateful incitement?”
  • Congressman Lee Zeldin: “Absolutely disgraceful & classless anti-Semitic pic…If I posted a pic like this, substituting this imagery w other ppl I opposed in politics & included religious symbols, the Times would report & editorialize on it calling for my head. Sick double standards at play.”
  • Adam Milstein, one of the first to tweet the image, “Another disgusting display of vile antisemitic trope celebrated in the @nytimesworld.   The NYT is signaling to the world that antisemitism is real, here, and welcome.” He also notes “The “artist” behind the vile anti Semitic cartoon published by the NY Times is Antonio Expresso of Lisbon Portugal.”  Actually the name of the cartoonist is “Antonio” and it appeared in Expresso.
  • Anshel Pfeffer “The NY Times cartoon of Netanyahu as guide-dog for blind Trump would also have been a harsh but fair depiction of their relationship. But the moment Trump has a kippah and Netanyahu a Star of David, it veered sharply in to antisemitic territory. Truly incredible it was published.”
  • The Persistence “We’ve seen enough Jewish hatred from democrat leaders, like Ilhan Omar, & now the media is outright attacking the Jewish community.”
  • Mark Dubowitz “For years, the NYT has normalized hatred for Israel. Now, it is normalizing hatred for Jews. Plus ça change, plus c’est la même chose.”
Screen Shot 2019-04-27 at 5.35.17 PM

The copy of the newspaper in Tel Aviv (Seth J. Frantzman)

  • Alex Pierson connects the cartoon the synagogue attack in California “have some thoughts and prayers to send to those Jews gunned down in their place of worship on the final day of pesach?!”
  • Lenny Ben-David “The NYT considers itself immune from criticism, protected by First Amendment. That’s not diplomatic immunity. Maybe the Israeli Foreign Ministry needs to call in NYT bureau chief to issue a demarche & warning that press credentials will be cancelled.”
  • Kay Wilson and David Abitbol note similarities to past anti-semitism
  • Campaign against Antisemitism “We are appalled to hear of the fatal shooting at Congregation Chabad of #Poway. Once again Klal Yisrael mourns innocents. The local mayor says the shooter hated Jews. Today, this was the cartoon in NYT” 
  • Deborah Lipstadt “Antisemitism does not come from one direction: it’s on the right and the left. If you only see it in the opposite side of where you stand politically then you are blind in at least one eye and turning the fight against it into a political weapon”
  • Seth Mandel “Perfect example of why it’s getting tougher to unite to fight antisemitism. The Paper of Record is printing pogromist toons, offers an ‘explanation’ that’s obvious bullshit and does not include an apology. Will the usual suspects shame NYT advertisers into pulling their business?”
  • Mike Doran “A question to the NYT: Had the dog represented a Muslim politician, say the Iranian FM Zarif, leading a blind Obama with a Mullah’s turban, would the editor signing off on this still work at the NYT? Or at any other respectable newspaper for that matter?”
  • Judah Ari Gross “You’d expect something more than ‘Whoops!’ Maybe a ‘We apologize'”
  • Amb. Daniel Shapiro “When I make an “error in judgment”, I apologize for it and make every effort to make amends. This particular one by the NYT requires that in spades. Still waiting.”
  • David Harris “The more I think about the NYT ‘cartoon,’ the more appalled I am. While #Antisemitism is rising…synagogues are attacked & Jews killed…democratic #Israel is demonized…& Jewish institutions are forced to bolster security…”
  • Alan Dershowitz ” a symptom of a deeper problem on the left. It’s acceptable to many on the left to employ anti Semitic tropes as long as they’re directed against Israel. Anti Zionism is becoming an acceptable cover for anti Semitism…owes its readers more than an apology. We are to entitled to an investigation and explanation: how did the anti Semitic cartoon get published? Who approved it? What steps are being taken to prevent a recurrence?”
  • Fleur Hassan-Nahoum “Absolutely disgusting… no words”
  • David Hazony “So. Are we clear now that NYT folks can no longer pin the rise of anti-Semitism on the far right? Retraction or not, nobody has done more to mainstream it than NYT in this one moment.”
  • Aamir Toumaj linked it to Iranian cartoons
  • Dan Crenshaw “Even if unintentional, the left has normalized anti-semitism under the guise of criticizing US-Israel foreign policy. It is radicalizing people. NYT was latest example along with their weak-at-best apology.”
  • Daniel Schwammenthal “Not even a community student paper ought to get away with such a Stürmer-sized “error of judgment”-particularly not if it has a history of anti-Israeli coverage. When Palestinian terror is routinely whitewashed and Jesus turned into a Palestinian, the problem is structural.”
  • Dominic Green at The Spectator US wrote an article condemning the cartoon. He noted what the ‘Times’ should have written: “‘We ran a blatantly anti-Semitic cartoon. At a time when anti-Jewish violence and incitement is at levels not seen since 1945, we chose to place gutter racism on our pages. We did this because plenty of our editors share the prejudice of this cartoon; if in doubt, look at our unsigned editorials.”

Updates

  • Lahav Harkov: “Source tells me NY Times office in NY was genuinely surprised and disturbed by the cartoon. Someone in the International NY Times office in France should answer for this.”
  • Luis Goldschmidt notes “In Portugal, the newspaper Expresso published the same cartoon last week. It is sign by Antonio, a famous Portuguese cartoonist. But Expresso told me it’s an editorial opinion. What a shame. The Jew is a dog! Terrible. Has the NYT copied the cartoon? It’s exactly the same one!” It appears further details on the cartoonist can be found here.
  • Axios claims the NYT apologized, even though it didn’t.
  • Free Beacon covers the cartoon scandal
  • The New York Times apologizes
  • Bret Stephens condemns the cartoon. “The Times published a despicable anti-Semitic cartoon this week in its international edition. Here’s my column about the cartoon, and the lessons the Times urgently needs to learn about the episode”

 

 

 

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s